215/45R17
Start going wider than that the steering feel will get squishy.
However, tire height will be a inch less than OEM, so the speedo will be a bit off. The gap between the wheel and the fender wil increase 1/2 inch.
If you want something closer to OEM size, a 50 series tire will be a better match.
If you can spend just a little more and want to keep with the multi spoke design, these are a step up:
Traklite Gear, 5x114, 45mm, Matte Gunmetal for MX5, 17x7.5
Don't go by the picture, its just a stock photo. The link goes to the 5x114.3 rims.
15.5 lbs vs 18.7, and flow formed, not cast. Lighter + stronger = better :smile2: