2004 to 2020 Mazda 3 Forum and Mazdaspeed 3 Forums banner

Need Help Deciding - Toyota Corolla vs Mazda3 - 2014

12K views 42 replies 28 participants last post by  Airfleet  
#1 ·
My '02 Ford Explorer has clocked around 138,000 miles on it and finally the costs of repair are becoming more than the cost of the car. It's time to get something new.

I would like to downsize and am looking in the compact car segment. I'm new to shopping for cars, I've driven that Explorer for 7 years. I have narrowed my search down to two cars I like, the Toyota Corolla LE and the Mazda3 i Sport (2014 model, not hatchback). I'm planning to buying the car new.

I've test driven both and found the Mazda3 was more pleasant and fun to drive, I enjoyed the sportiness of it. I found the Toyota to have a lot more bang for the buck as far as features, with the touchscreen and backup camera in every model.

I'd like to get at least 100,000 miles out of the car, I plan to drive it for at least 7-8 years like my current vehicle. As it stands, these cars are neck and neck for me and I'm looking for advice from those who have driven these to help sway me one way or the other.

I know toyota has a good track record, with corolla's being one of the top selling cars ever, I know less about Mazda. I think it comes down to reliability for me, I'd like the car I'll be sending to the shop less often and will cost me less in the long run.

With the recent Mazda3 being an all new design, I'm fairly concerned that looking at reviews of older models will not give me a good sense of the quality of the car model. Also, J.D. Power gave it 2 out of 5 stars, which is rather startling but not helpful, given everyone else is singing it's praises and J.D. Power does not list the reasons why they gave these scores. Can Anyone explain to me where these low scores came from?

Any help is much appreciated! I've been sitting on this decision for a few days.
 
#34 ·
Wow, this thread blew up, thanks for the responses! I ended up getting a great deal on the Mazda3 so I went with that, it was just more enjoyable to drive. It IS one from Mexico, built 6/11/14. The car had 20 miles on it when I got it, currently at 150 and it's running quite nicely. Hopefully no problems will come up due to the Mexican manufacturing...So far I'm really happy with the purchase!
 
#38 ·
Honda Civic = Ninth generation, Mazda 3 = third generation. Anyone who drives a car to 200k + miles is gambling on major repair costs. No matter what the car make. Not every car, of any make, is a sure deal to that mileage. I had a new '97 Honda Civic scatter the tranny at 130k, along with other non-routine repairs along the way. Others, I'm sure, made it to 200k, some didn't. The only time I ever kept a new car beyond 80k and paid for it in repair costs. It's basically, a luck of the draw, on getting 200k out of any new car whether it's a Honda, Mazda, Toyota, ect. and no one is psychic enough to know which cars will make it to that point, with modest repair bills.
 
#40 ·
Yea I made my decision as well and am waiting for the 2015 models to come out then i will buy mine in November/December :) thank you everyone for the feedback !
 
#42 ·
I just had a funny vision of him signing up for hte Mazda forum and then signing up for the Toyota forum and asking the same question.

Here he'd get a bunch of passionate responses about driving dynamics and whatnot.

AT the Toyota forum he'd get a bunch of guys saying "Well, it didn't break again!" and then posting videos of grass growing.